宋代“江西词派”商榷

Discussion of Jiangxi Ci-School in the Song Dynasty

两宋时期,江西地区涌现出较多的词人,取得了比全国大多数地区词人都要突出的成就,但由于他们的词学理论、词作风格及领袖人物都与全国其他地区词人相一致而未形成自己的区域特色,故不足于形成"江西词派",有的论者所提出的两宋"江西词派"之说并不成立,宋代江西词人是以词人群体的方式活跃在两宋词坛上的。

During the Song dynasty, many Ci-writers emerged in Jiangxi Area and achieved more outstanding success than those in most of the other places of the country. For this reason, some critics advanced 'Jiangxi Ci-school'. After a careful investigation and analysis, the author of this article thinks that there is no sufficient proof of the formation of 'Jiangxi Ci-school' because the theory, the artistic style and the leading characters of Jiangxi Ci-writers during the Song dynasty corresponded to those in other parts of the country and, therefore, did not possess or display their own local characteristics. In fact, they were very active in the Ci-world in the way of 'groups of Ci-writers'.