走出行政行为公定力的理论困境——对沈岿教授的部分回应

Walking Out the Academic Puzzledom of Presumptive Rightfulness of the Administrative Act ——Partial Responses to Prof ShenKui

在行政行为诸效力中,学界对公定力的争议最大。不但对公定力应否存在具有重大分歧,甚至在有限公定力说的阵营内部也存在诸多争论。沈岿教授曾撰文指出了使公定力理论走出困境所必须解决的六大问题,除了最后两个涉及刑事诉讼和民事诉讼的问题外,前四个问题可一一作出回应,以拨开长久以来笼罩在公定力之上的浓雾,帮助公定力走出所面临的困境,进而推动行政行为效力研究的发展。

Among all the effectiveness of administrative act,presumptive rightfulness gains the most debates.This kind of debate incarnated on many points,not only on the rationality about the existence of presumptive rightfulness,but also on the disagreements in the faction which protest the limited presumptive rightfulness.Let the presumptive rightfulness walks out its puzzledom,Prof ShenKui pointed out six questions which must be solved in a discourse.Except for the last two questions which are involved Criminal La...