电子警察的司法审查——从上海黄浦分局交通行政处罚案谈起

Judicial Review of the Electronic Police——Starting from the Traffic Administrative Punishment Case of Shanghai Huangpu Branch

通过分析上海市黄浦分局交通行政处罚案,归纳电子警察司法审查的争议点,梳理法院作出的回应和据此形成的类型化裁判规则,提出可以从形成过程、明显性、实际效果等方面对设备进行实体审查,并从事前、事中及事后角度对电子警察执法方式进行综合检视。

By analyzing the traffic administrative punishment case of Shanghai Huangpu Branch,this article summarizes the disputes of the electronic police judicial review,sorts out the court's response and the typed judgment rules formed accordingly.It puts forward the view that it can conduct physical inspection of equipment from the aspects of formation process,obviousness,actual effect,etc.,and form a comprehensive review of electronic police law enforcement methods from the perspectives of before,during and after the event.