摘要
环境行政公益诉讼制度是中国对于解决环境资源侵害问题的一项创新性法律制度,对于保护环境资源意义重大。如何认定行政机关“不依法履行职责”在制度运行过程中居于特别重要的地位,而我国法律对这一关键问题并未作出明确规定。在对理论界及司法实务过程中形成的行为标准、结果标准、复合标准、二阶层说的核心观点、理论依据以及弊端或缺陷等内容进行分析后,提出环境行政公益诉讼中“不依法履行职责”的认定标准应以结果标准为原则,以行为标准为补充。
The environmental administrative public interest litigation system is an innovative legal system in China to solve the problem of environmental resources infringement,which is of great significance for the protection of environmental resources.How to determine the administrative organs“not in accordance with the law to perform their duties”in the operation of the system in the process of a particularly important position,and China's law on this key issue has not made clear provisions.In the theoretical and judicial practice of the formation of the behavioral standard,the results of the standard,the composite standard,the core,viewpointsthe theoretical basis of the two-class theory and drawbacks or defects and other content analysis,the environmental administrative public interest litigation,“not in accordance with the law to perform their duties”should be determined by the results of the standard as a principle,supplemented by the standard of the standard of the behavior.
作者
李一君
武俊山
LI Yijun;WU Junshan(Department of Law,Xinzhou Normal University,Xinzhou 034000,China;Beijing Celue Law Firm Taiyuan Office,Taiyuan 030000,China)
出处
《忻州师范学院学报》
2024年第2期33-38,63,共7页
Journal of Xinzhou Teachers University
关键词
环境行政公益诉讼
不依法履行职责
认定标准
行为标准
结果标准
environmental administrative public interest litigation
not performing duties in accordance with law
determination standard
behavioral standard
result standard