论当前“文化政治”讨论中有关“文化认同”的方法论问题

On the Methodological Problem of the Discussions of “Chinese Identity” in the Exploration of “Cultural Politics”

自20世纪90年代以来,中国学者就在国际舞台上如何建立中国人的主体性和认同的问题进行了持续的思考。张旭东2005年初版、2021年三版的理论著作《全球化时代的文化认同》在文化界引发了热烈的讨论,其影响延续至今。本文对比剖析张旭东与其论争对手的观点,检视它们各自观点主张与方法论的优缺点。

Since the late 1990s,Chinese scholars have deliberated on the issue of the establishment of a Chinese cultural subjectivity and identity for a nation rising in the international arena.Zhang Xudong’s theoretical work Cultural Identity in the Era of Globalization,published in the year 2005,sparked heated debate within intellectual circles,and continued its broad influence till now.This article aims to bring Zhang’s thesis and its opponents’opinions together,to examine their concerns and respective methodologies and shed lights on their merits and faults.