浅析法律论证理论视域中的民事诉讼理论——以阿列克西理论为切入点的分析

An Analysis of Civil Procedure on the Theories of Legal Justification——Based on the Legal Argumentation of Robert Alexy

籍由阿列克西"实践正确性的程序理论",程序理念的进化和程序性的技术客观上有助于个案评价的理性辨别、判断和选择,并能够对判决的形成过程施加理性的控制。因此在法律论证理论的视域中,通过对我国民事诉讼理论、程序架构、以及具体程序运作的分析,尝试为程序取向的判决正当化机制提供新的解释路径。

How can judges get a proper judgment through civil procedure and how to find the reasons for judicial decisions in specific cases by rational and procedural legal argumentation is an unresolved question in civil judicial practices and modern theories of legal methods.This paper makes an attempt to answer this question by introducing,analyzing and criticizing the theory of legal argumentation and the procedural theory of practical correctness.Although we can t definitely reach an agreement and achieve consen...