怎样看待中学语文教材中的鲁迅作品——评韩石山《中学课本里的鲁迅作品》

How to Look Upon the Works by Lu Xun Adopted in the Text Books of Chinese in Middle Schools——A Comment on Han Shi-shan's《Works by Lu Xun Adopted in the Text Books of Chinese in Middle Schools》

作家韩石山对《药》、《阿Q正传》、《社戏》、《故乡》等鲁迅作品入选不同版本的中学语文教材提出若干质疑,本文则力图据实据理地指出韩文在艺术评判、逻辑运用及文体辨析等方面的偏颇失当之处。

Han Shi-shan,the writer,raises several queries on the works by Lu Xun such as《Medicine》,《The True Story of Ah Q》,《Village Opera》,《My Old Home》etc.,adopted in the different editions of middle school courses of Chinese.This article,based on facts and reasons,tries to point out the biases of Han's critics of art,application of logic and the style of differentiation and analysis.