论聚众淫乱行为不应纳入犯罪圈

On the Gang-bang Should Not Be Included in Criminal Circle

我国《刑法》第301条第一款规定了聚众淫乱罪,但将此种涉及隐秘私生活的行为界定为刑事犯罪,并不是其他国家普遍的做法。从法益侵害理论、刑法谦抑性原则、罪刑法定原则、刑法价值论等角度衡量,将聚众淫乱行为犯罪化缺乏合理性基础,在一定程度上呈现了国家刑罚权的滥用,是刑法对道德领域的入侵,易导致刑罚的负价值。因此应将聚众淫乱行为排除在犯罪圈之外。

Article 301,paragraph 1 of the Criminal Law states the gang-bang crime,but defines such acts involves secretive private life as a criminal offense,that is not a common practice in other countries.From the theory of violating legal interests,restraining principle of criminal law,principal of a legally prescribed punishment for a specified crime,and the value of the Penal Code,criminalizing gang-bang lack of rationality.To some extent,it reflect the state abuse its rights of penalties;and is moral invasion of...