关于形式解释论的几点澄清——兼论罪刑法定视域下的形式解释论

Several Clarification of the Formal Interpretation Theory: And A Discussion of it on The Principle of Legality

法律之生命在于解释和应用,却天生带有一定的粗糙和不足。对于刑法规范的解释运用,如何在形式解释论与实质解释论之间做出选择,是一个刑法的立场问题,也是刑法方法论的路径选择问题。文章阐述了实质解释论的基本观点,对形式解释论做出几点澄清,并进一步在罪刑法定原则展开了对形式解释论更为合理和优越的讨论。

The life of law lies in the interpretation and application,but it is born to be much rough and deficient.It is a question involving the standpoint of criminal law and the path choosing of the methodology of criminal law that we should make the interpretation and application to the criminal law how we make a choice between the formal and substantive interpretation theories.This essay presents the basic viewpoints of the substantive interpretation theory at first,then makes a clarification of the formal interpretation theory,and develops the discussion of it on the Principle of Legality at last.