对“重新审度三级跳远的极值与各跳最佳组合的研究方法”中质疑的商榷

Discussing on Some Issues:‘The Re-determination of the Limit for Triple Jump’and‘Research Method of the Optimal Combination for Jumps’

“对未来三级跳远的极值和各跳远度及比例发展趋势的建模与探索”与“重新审度三级跳远的极值与各跳最佳组合的研究方法”两文都是研究的三极跳远状态，但是两文探索的论点、论据、样本、方法和目标时空（前者是研究未来，后者讨论的是当今）都完全不一样，不存在重新审度的支点。要求预测模型，特别是中长期和超长期的预测数学模型“必须考虑１５个变量，再加上人体各生理指标或人体能力指标”是不现实的幻想，完全不可信，也无任何运用价值，用不具外推功能，又无实践检验的回归方程，去超范围的强求三级跳最佳组合模式是不严肃、不科学的。

Both‘The model a nd in vestigation on the limit it of futu re triple jump anddeveloping tendency of the Limit for Triple Jump’and‘The Re-determination of the Limit for TripleJump’and‘Research Method of the Optimal Combination for Jumps ’envolved to study the state oftriple jump.But the arguments,grounds,samples,methods and targets in two paper were quitedifferent and there was no a fulcrum for the re-determination.Aad it is not actual,but just an illusionthat the predicting models,especially for,should put the 15 variables,plusing physiological indexes,under consideration.