陈尚君《汉唐文学与文献论考》指瑕

The Flaws of On the Literature of Tang Dynasty by Chen Shangjun

陈尚君《汉唐文学与文献论考》存在一些明显错误。别集应当定义为"别集是收录一人作品的集子",总集应当定义为"总集是收录多人作品的集子"。其中之作品既可是文学作品也可是非文学作品。选集是收录一人部分作品的集子,而全集是收录一人全部作品的集子,选集和全集属于别集,选集和全集与总集无关。

There are some mistakes in On the literature of Tang dynasty by Chen Shangjun.The defini-tion of BIE JI should be that BIE JI is a collection which selects or collects works which are of either litera-ture or non-literature by one author and the definition of ZONGJI should be that ZONGJI is a collection which selects or collects works which are of either literature or non-literature by many authors.The definition of XUANJI should be that XUANJI which belongsto BIEJIisa collection which selects works which are of either literature or non-literature by one author and the definition of QUANJI should be that QUANJI which belongs to BIE JI is a collection which collects works which are of either literature or non-literature by one author.Either XUANJI or QUANJI is independent of ZONGJI.