《大国政治的悲剧》霸权逻辑的脆弱性——评约翰·米尔斯海默的“中国威胁论”

A Comment on John Mearsheimer's Menacing Theory of China

由于美国学者约翰·米尔斯海默的《大国政治的悲剧》这本书刚出版不久 ,所以目前国内对约翰·米尔斯海默的国际政治理论进行研究的并不多 ,从逻辑结构的角度进行研究的更为鲜见。作者与约翰·米尔斯海默教授的辩论内容主要包括 5个部分 :逻辑起点 :进攻性现实主义辨析 ;逻辑支点 :民主和平论辨析 ;逻辑基点 :人口和财富辨析 ;逻辑推论 :“一个国家要想生存下去就必然成为霸权国家”辨析 ;

Owing to Tragedy of Great Power Politics by John Mearsheimer just publishing ,up to now domestic scholars rarely research John Mearsheimer's theory of international politics ,especially from the angle of logical structure. The thesis try to analyse his theory of international politics to find out the roots of its theoretical system landing in a predicament on the unanimous basis of history and logic from a new angle. The thesis includes five parts: starting point of logic——the discrimination of attacking realism; fulcrum of logic——the discrimination of theory of democracy and peace; basic point of logic——the discrimination of population and wealth; inference of logic——if a state want to exist, it must become a state of supremacy; conclusion.