关于赋予我国判例拘束力的定位分析

The Analysis of Power Location for the Legal Precedent of Our Country

先例判决制度的施行引发了社会各界对判例定位问题的重新思考。尽管理论界对把判例制度引入我国 ,并将判例作为我国法律渊源之一的讨论已有十余年 ,但真正以制度的形式赋予判例拘束力这还是第一次。本文通过考察先例判决制度在我国的施行状况 ,比较两大法系国家判例拘束力的法律定位 ,结合我国的司法现状 。

The enforcement of verdict system according to the precedents arouses the new thinking about the issue of how to position the precedents. Although the system of precedent has bee theoretialy introduced into our country and has been discussed as one of the origins of our country's law for over ten years, it is the first time to impose the binding force on the verdict in the from of system. By examining the present situation of the enforcement of verdict system according to the precedents in our country, comparing the legal positioning of the state's binding force on the verdict in these two countries, and analyzing the present judicial state in our country, this paper puts forward the ways to realize the binding force on the verdict in of our country.