《金朝军制》平议——兼评王曾瑜先生的辽金史研究

A Comment on The Military System of the Jin Dynasty——Also on the Study of the History of the Liao and Jin dynasties by Mr.Wang Zhenyu

《金朝军制》是迄今为止有关金朝军事制度最为全面系统的研究成果 ,其学术价值应充分肯定 ,但此书也存在不足之处。 2 0世纪的辽金史研究之所以始终比较沉寂 ,在各断代史研究中处于相对落后的地位 ,其根本症结就在于史料太少 ,而且由于没有新史料的重大发现 ,无缘形成学术新潮流。因此 ,2 1世纪的辽金史研究必须从上下、左右两个方向去寻求突破。

The Military System of the Jin Dynasty is the most comprehensive and systematic study of the military system of the Jin dynasty known to date, and its academic value should be fully recognized. However, the work also has shortcomings. The study of the history of the Liao and Jin dynasties lags far behind research on the history of other dynasties. The main reason is that there are far too few historical materials; there have been no new discoveries of important historical materials which has resulted in insufficient study of the topic. In the 21st century, the study of the history of the Liao and Jin dynasties will depend on new historical materials, although Wang Zengyus work does provide some inspirations.