对金庸小说的论争透视

Perspectivity of the Arguments Towards Jin Yong' s Novels

对金庸小说的论争暴露了学术界所存在的许多问题。这其中既有作家、批评家商业化的介入;也有学者理论上的含混不清、学术态度不严谨等。促使金庸小说论争陷入较浅的层次和无意义的辩驳之中,阻碍了金庸小说研究的深入。本文为图透视并澄清金庸小说论争中的雅俗和经典之争的等若干理论问题,以此为金庸小说进入经典文学史做点规范的工作。

Arguments towards Jin Yong's novels have revealed many problems existing in the academic fields. Amomg them, there are problems concerning the intervention by commercialized writers, criticsconfued theories put forward by scholars as well as the not sovigrousscholarshi which have put Jin Yong' s novels into superficial and meaningless arguments and have prevented people from further study into Jin Yong's novels. This paper has attempted to grasp and clarify several theoretician problems in Jin Yong' s novels concerning the arguments of the refined and popular and the classics. Based on these, the author of the present study has tried to do something according to the norms so as to let the entrance of Jin Yong's novels into the history of classic literature.