“楚不用吴起而削乱”质疑

Query On "the Chu Kingdom Was Weaken Without Using Wuqi′s Reform"

“楚不用吴起而削乱”是韩非子对吴起变法的评价 ,学者们也都认同 ,然而 ,《战国策》、《史记》却认为吴起变法是成功的 ,并且 ,近年来楚地日益丰富的考古成果也证明 ,楚国在吴起变法以后并没有削乱 ,而是保持着上升的发展趋势 ,因此 ,不能说“楚不用吴起而削乱”。

It was Han Feizi's commentary that 'the Chu Kingdo m was weaken without using Wuqi's Reform'. The idea is followed by many scholars. The documentary and archaeological materials indicate Chu Kingdom was not weaken . The author doesn't think so. The article proves that Wuqi's reform lasted ten years or also. And it was effectual. After the reform, the Chu Kingdom became st ronger and more prosperous than ever. As a result, Wuqi's reform was successful and it was devoted greatly to the development of the Chu Kingdom.