辩证逻辑应是逻辑而不是哲学——对金顺福先生主编《辩证逻辑》一书的评析

Dialectic Logic is Not philosophy but Logic——Anatysis on《Dialectic Logic》by Jin Shunfu

金顺福先生主编的《辩证逻辑》一书在一些内容上存有值得商榷之处,具体地体现在以下几方面:1.根据“辩证逻辑乃是研究人类辩证思维的形式、规律和方法的科学”的共识,辩证逻辑的对象应是辩证思维形式及其规律而不是思维形式的辩证法;2.确实存在着与普通思维形式不同的辩证思维形式———辩证概念、辩证命题、辩证推理等;3.概念、命题(判断)等确实存在着辩证法,但这是思维形式的辩证法,它属于辩证法研究的对象。辩证逻辑的对象是辩证思维形式,不是思维形式的辩证法。辩证逻辑必须从哲学中脱离出来。

There are some contents worthy of discussion in Dialectic Logic edited chiefly by Jin Shun Fu. Exacthy speaking, they are embodied as the followings:1.According to the common knowledge, dialectic Logic is the science of studying the formdlity, regulations and methods of human dialectic thinking, so the object studied by dialetic logic should be the formalities and regulations of dialetical thinking rather than dialectic of thinking formlities. 2.Dialecticaal thinking formalities that are different from the ordinary ones do exist-dialetic concepts, dialetic proposition, dialetic inference. 3.The dialetic that does lie in concepts and proposition is the dialetic of thinking formality and belongs to the objects studied by dialetic. The object of dialectic logic is not the dialectic of thinking formality but the dialectical thinking formality. Dialectic logic must be freed from philosophy.