《吴越春秋》“殆非全书”辨识

Differentiation and Analysis about the Wu Yue Chun Qiu was "Generally not the Whole Book

东汉赵晔所撰《吴越春秋》，隋唐《经籍志》皆著录为十二卷，自元至今所存各种版本均为十卷，元徐天祜指其“殆非全书”。本文援引《史记》注、〈文选》注及《水经注》，辨析了“殆非全书”说的正误，揭示出所佚两卷的核心内容及其卷次，指出前入所谓所佚两卷为“西施至吴”和“范蠡去越”不能成立。

Wuyue Chunqiu written by Zhao Ye in the Eastern Han dynasty recorded by Jing Ji Zhi in sui and Tang Dynasties was twelve rolls,but from Yuan dynasty till now,all kinds of editions were ten rolls. So XU Tian-you pointed out that the book was 'generally not the whole book'. The article differentiates and analyes the corrections and crrors of the statement by quoting the annotation of Shi Ji, Wen Xuan and Shui jing zhu, reveals the core content of missed two rolls, the 'Xi Shi arrived Wu kingdom'and'Fan Li went to Yue kingdom'. The two rolls were not existed.