法学基础范畴的重构:对权利和权力的新思考被引量：7

Reconstruction of Law Basis: Reconsideration on Right and Power

导出

摘要 "权力"与"权利"是法学研究中的一般概念,也是许多理论分析的逻辑起点。目前,那种将"权力"界定为国家权力、将"权利"界定为一般民众权利的思维定式,需要认真地予以反思。在法的空间中,"合法性"和"支配力"是法律权利不可缺少的两个组成部分。无论是国家,还是一般民众,其依法获得的支配性力量都属于法律权利。这样界定"法律权利"不仅更为符合法律活动的特征,而且,还有助于我们进一步讨论不同法律权利的正当性基础以及它们的现实效力等问题。 Power and right are basic conceptions in the study of law and logic starting points in theoretical an- alyzing. At present, the thinking formulary that power is defined as the power of state and right is defined as the right of common people should be seriously turned over to think. In the world of law, legitimacy and controlling power are two in- dispensable parts of legal right. Whether state or common people have the controlling power according to law, the control- ling power is legal right in the same way. The defining of legal right will be in keeping with the character of legal activity more accurately. Moreover, the defining will help us to further discuss the legitimacy bases and real effectiveness of dif- ferent legal rights.

作者王莉君

机构地区中国青年政治学院法律系

出处《法学家》 CSSCI 北大核心 2005年第2期118-124,共7页 The Jurist

关键词法学基础新思考法律权利重构范畴 “权利” “权力” 正当性基础法学研究逻辑起点国家权力思维定式民众权利组成部分法律活动界定支配力合法性效力 power right legitimacy controlling power

分类号 D90 [政治法律—法学理论]

引文网络
相关文献

参考文献21

1[美]丹尼斯·朗陆震纶译.《权力论》[M].[北京]中国社会科学出版社,2001年版..
2[日]美浓部达吉.黄冯明译.《公法与私法》[M].中国政法大学出版社,2003年版.第72-73页.
3Carl Wellman, An Approach to Rights, the Netherlands: Kluwer Academic Publishers, 1997, p4.p66—67.
4[德]马克斯·韦伯.林荣远译.《经济与社会》上卷[M].商务印书馆,1997年版.第81页.
5王莉君,孙国华.论权力与权利的一般关系[J].法学家,2003(5):107-113. 被引量：21
6[美]丹尼斯·朗著.陆震纶郑明哲译.《权力论》[M].中国社会科学出版社,2001年版.第29页,第56-58页.
7Peter M.Blan, Exchange and Power in Social Life, New York: John Wiley and Sons, 1964, p209.
8Neil MacCormick, "Right, Claim and Remedies", in M.A. Steward (ed.), Law, Morality and Rights,D. Reidel Publishing Company, 1979, p165, p166.
9Walter Wheeler Cooker, "Introduction", in W. N. Hohfeld, Ftmdamental Legal Conceptions as Applied in Judicial Reasoning, W.W. Cook ed., Lon-don: Yale University Press, 1923, p7.
10W.N.Hdafeld, Fundamental Legal Conceptions as Applied in Judicial Reasoning, W.W.Cook ed., London: Yale University Press, 1923, p51-52.p60.p52.