对金庸武侠小说批评的思考

Reflection On the Criticism of Jinyong's Wuxia Novels

金庸现象的出现对评论界形成了不小的冲击。在一些学者认真思考这种现象并潜心研究金庸武侠小说的时候,学术界发出了另外一种声音:拒绝金庸。本文针对金庸武侠小说所遭受的批评进行了思考,逐一分析了金庸武侠小说的批评者们的三个具有代表性的观点,指出了他们对金庸武侠小说的偏见和误解,澄清了他们对金庸武侠小说的错误认识。

Jinyong phenomenon shocks the critical circles. When some experts in the academic circles reflect on it and study Jinyong's novels, others voiced another sound: refusing Jinyong. The author reflects on the criticism Jinyong's novels sustain, analyzes one by one the three representative views the critics hold on Jinyong's novels, points out and clarifies their bias and misunderstanding against them.