转形问题真的“最终解决”了吗?——评张忠任先生关于转形问题的解法

Have We Settled the Question of Transformation

张忠任先生在《价值转形问题的最终解决》一文和《百年难题的破解》一书中宣称,转形问题已经由他最终解决。本文对此提出质疑,认为张忠任先生在求解转形问题时,一方面完全误解和曲解了转形问题的性质,其解法不过是温特尼茨模型和米克模型杂乱无章的混合物;另一方面,在证明“一致性命题”和求证方程组正数解时,其解法存在着明显的数学错误和漏洞。

The question of transformation is a theoretical difficulties in economics. Comrade Zhang Zhongren said he had settled the question, this essay doesn't think so. When comrade Zhang Zhong-ren answered the question of transformation, on the one hand, he made misunderstanding on the nature of transformation, his answer was a mixture of some economic models of western economists, on the other hand, there was mathematical mistaken in his method with which he tried to prove the proposition of identity and the positive solution of equations.