丘处机麾下全真道士不是《西游记》的最早作者——与胡义成先生商榷

The Earliest Author of A Journey to the West Should Not Be Quanzhen Taoist Priests under QIU Chu-ji ——Discuss with Mr. HU Yi-cheng

针对近年来学术界否定吴承恩力主丘处机麾下全真道徒为百回本《西游记》最早作者的观点,作者从道教与《西游记》、茅山与《西游记》、虞集序真伪与《西游记》等关系正本清源,驳斥胡义成等立论暨论据的错误,指出百回本《西游记》最早作者绝不是丘处机麾下的全真道徒。

In recent years, some scholars in academic circles maintain that the earliest author of A Journey to the west should be Quanzhen Taoist priests under QIU Chu-ji instead of WU Cheng-en. To counter such viewpoint, the write here thoroughly clarifies the relations between Taoism and A Journey to the West, Mountain Mao and the latter, and Yuji＇s preface and the latter. The writer points out the errors of Mr. HU Yi-cheng＇s argument and stresses that the earliest author of A Journey to the west should, in no case, be Quanzhen Taoist priests under QIU Chu-ji stract.