浅析医疗红包的法律定性

Analysis on Determining the Legal Nature of Red Paper Containing Money as a Gift in Hospital

医生收受红包的行为是否构成犯罪,法学界对此有两种截然不同的观点,一种认为应按受贿罪论处,另一种认为医生不符合受贿罪的主体资格,不构成受贿罪。文章从犯罪构成的四个要件,结合医疗红包现象本身的性质、特点进行分析,认为由于医疗红包性质特殊和成因多样,不能一概而论地定位犯罪。同时,针对法律实施中存在的空白点,结合目前的法律实践经验,提供了可借鉴的法律救济途径。

Weather the doctor accpept the incentive form of money one be defined crime or not, the ;awyer has two quite different point.one consider that it is crime, the other insist that it is not crime because the doctor don＇t have the corpus qualification of bribe crime.The paper did the analysis from the crime＇s four key point combining the characters of the medical in centive form of money and conclude because the mdeical incentive form of money has special characters and diyersity reasons it can＇t be fully divined cirme,In other way, we find the law＇s blank point in bringing it into efffect and provide a way to relieve it combining the law practical experient.