国家赔偿违法原则质疑

On the Suspicion to Law-violating Principle in the Government Indemnity

理论界普遍认为我国国家赔偿归责原则是违法原则。而国家赔偿归责原则作为部门法的特别归责原则应符合损害赔偿总的归责原则理论体系,同时兼顾国家赔偿制度的特殊性。由此思路初步证明两点：一是违法原则的独立存在缺乏理论基础；二是国家追偿归责原则也应纳入国家赔偿归责原则体系。所以要摒弃违法原则,重新认识我国国家赔偿归责原则体系。

According to the general idea about the imputation standard of the government indemnity, the law-violating principle has validity in our country. But the author thinks that the government imputation standard should conform to the general imputation standard and the characteristics of the government indemnity law. So the author throws light on the two points： first, the by-law principle has no theoretical base; second, we should put the government additional indemnity to be the part of the imputation system of the government indemnity.