刘喜海对陈介祺的影响考绎

Unraveling the Influence of Liu Xihai on Chen Jieqi

陈介祺为咸同以来金石学第一人,已基本为学界所公认。然而我们金石学界对陈介祺的研究仍停留在讨论、证明这一话题的层面上,难免重复累赘之嫌。本文试图冲破这一樊篱,对陈介祺师承刘喜海的史实加以钩沉,以期丰富对陈介祺的学术研究。本文分别从人际关系的角度、刘喜海在同道心目中的地位、刘喜海藏品为陈介祺购藏使用以及陈介祺对刘喜海收藏特点所带有的模仿痕迹、陈介祺治学精神与刘喜海的诸多相似之处等四个方面在排比史实的基础上加以合理考绎,论证了年长陈介祺二十岁且享名甚早的刘喜海对晚辈陈介祺的治学、收藏所产生的种种影响。

Chen Jieqi being the number one of epigra phy since the periods of Xianfeng and Tongzhi has been generally acknowledged by academic circles. However, our epigraphy circle stays the level of argumentation and testification, hard to avoid the repetitions a nd encumbrances. The thesis verifies them with reas on in four respects: in the viewpoint of the relations a mong them; the station of Liu Xihai in the mental view of the contemporary; Chen Jieqi purchasing and using the collections of Liu Xihai and imitating the ways of Liu's collecting; and the same spirit of Chert Jieqi's pursuing his studies as Liu Xihai etc., based on the historical facts, and demonstrates the influences of older Liu Xihai on the studies and collections of younger Chen Jieqi.