杜严“睚眦”考,反证多隐匿——与丁启阵先生商榷

The Quotation about Du Fu's Poems in the Inspection on the Contradiction between Du Fu and Yan Wu Are almost Uncorrect: A Discussion with Mr.Ding Qizhen

丁启阵先生在《杜甫、严武“睚眦”考辨》一文中引用了大量杜诗来证明杜甫、严武之间发生过“睚眦”,然而对于所引杜诗如《哭严仆射归榇》等分析多不够客观,尚需重新解读;且最能说明杜甫、严武之间关系深厚的《八哀诗.赠左仆射郑国公严公武》和《诸将五首》其五,丁文却都没有全篇引用并加以解析,难免有隐匿反证之嫌。

Mr. Ding Qizhen＇ s Inspection on the Contradiction between Du Fu and Yan Wu cited many Du Fu＇s poems to prove the contradiction between Du Fu and Yan Wu, but its analysis on Du Fu＇s poems such as Crying the going back of Yan Wu＇ s remains, isn＇ t objective, needs to analyse again. One of the Eight Crying Poems to Yan Wu and Five Poems about Many Generals which can best show the deep feeling between Du Fu and Yah Wu, are not cited by Ding＇ s paper, this possibly conceal contrary proof.