摘要
佘祥林案存在的问题反映了中国司法活动过程中最具代表性的问题,即程序的非正义性。要实现程序正义,有赖于司法主体摒弃“有罪推定”的传统思维定势,坚持“无罪推定”的司性理性;有赖于司法者坚持司法自治原则,排除外力干扰,依法独立办案;同时也有赖于司法者坚持法律至上性,依法保障诉权的实现。这三个问题也是限制当前中国司法秩序建设的关键性因素。一个良好的司法秩序只能靠法治,有法律规制的程序正义才是司法秩序健康发展的根本保障。
She Xiangdin Case reflects what is most characteristic in Chinese judicial processes: the injustice of procedures. In order to realize the justice of procedures, first of all, the judicial branch will have to abolish the traditional' guilt hypothesis' and adhere to' innocence rationale' ; secondly it will have to stick to its self-reliance principle, resist interferences and reach verdicts independently; lastly it will have to pursue the superiority of law and guarantee the right of appellation. These are the three key factors determining the development of Chinese judicial system. Law government is essential to a good judicial system. A lawful procedure justice is a requisite for the healthy development of judicial order.
出处
《河北法学》
CSSCI
北大核心
2006年第5期95-100,共6页
Hebei Law Science
基金
湖南省教育厅科研课题<国际人权公约与中国弱势群体人权法律制度研究>(04C416)成果之一
关键词
程序正义
司法理性
司法自治
诉权
procedure justice
judicial rationale
judicial self-reliance
the right of appellation