对本科教学工作水平评估中毕业设计评审的分析和建议

Analysis and Suggestion of Graduation Project Evaluation in Undergraduate Teaching Level Evaluation

毕业设计(论文)的评审是本科教学工作水平评估的重要环节。通过对2003年部分参评工科院校的毕业设计(论文)的评估数据进行统计分析,结果显示,学校对毕业设计(论文)的评估结果优于专家的评估结果,专家进校考察时抽调的毕业设计(论文)的评定成绩和前期抽调的毕业设计(论文)的评定成绩并没有特别明显的差异。因此,本科教学工作水平评估有必要进行相应的改进,如进一步规范毕业设计(论文)评阅表,加强专家的遴选与培训工作,加强毕业设计(论文)抽调的管理和组织工作。同时,毕业设计(论文)的质量评估可以考虑次数。

The evaluation of graduation project （thesis） is a very important procedure in the evaluation of teaching level in undergraduate teaching level evaluation. This paper analyzed the data from the graduation project （thesis） evaluation in some universities of engineering, which were evaluated in 2003. The result showed that the assessment result by the universities was superior to that by experts, and that the difference between the assessment result of graduation project （thesis） draw-out before and after the experts entered the university was not obvious. Finally, this paper gave some suggestions to the teaching level evaluation in universities.