论利益衡量的规制——从腾房案的实证分析出发

On Regulation of Interest Balance -From the Point of View of Analytic Demonstration of House-emptying Case

以日本学者提出的利益衡量论为研究对象,通过分析其理论形成的历史沿革,结合我国目前的法制状况, 揭示其种种弊端:容易导致恣意、衡量标准的不确定、缺乏程序和方法的控制。因此,对司法过程中的利益衡量应当寻求相对客观的标准加以规制。

According to the Interest Balance Theory proposed by Japanese scholars, analyzing the history of the theory＇ s growth and linking with legal system in our country at present, the article reveals many malpractiees, which will easily result in practice with arbitrariness; uncertainty of balance standards; lack of regulation of procedures and methods. Therefore, the interest balance should be regulated by objective standards that we make great efforts to seek in the course of justice.