学校管理司法介入的限度

On the Extent of Judicial Intervention in School Administration

由于学生基本权利的不可侵犯性与学校自主管理的教育规律,司法介入公立学校管理存在一定的限度。这具体表现为三个方面:涉及基本权利的管理行为方属于司法介入范围;复议前置程序是司法介入的前提条件;程序审查是司法审查的主要标准。只有如此,学校管理、学生权利与司法独立三者之间才能保持良性互动。

There should be limitation for judicial intervention in school administration because of the inviolability of the basic rights of students and the rules of school administration. The limitation is embodied in three aspects： firstly, the scope of judicial intervention should be limited to administration dealing with the basic rights of students; secondly, the Administrative Reconsideration Preposition should be the precondition of judicial intervention; thirdly, procedure review is the main standard for judicial review. Only in such ways can school administration, student rights and judicial independence act well with each other.