瑕不掩瑜,去之更佳——再与黄伯荣等先生商榷

Small Defects Cannot Obscure Great Virtues,But No Defect Is Better——Discuss with Mr.Huang

在充分肯定黄伯荣、廖序东先生主编的《现代汉语》教材的前提下,笔者在教学中陆续发现一些值得商榷之处:“非常”的词性、“共同”的归类、“同位短语”举例质疑、“所”字短语举例质疑、宾语前置的质疑、变式句的质疑、是框式还是梯式、多重复句内部结构关系的确定等,就上述问题笔者提出不同意见,愿与业内人士磋商。

Based on the affirmation of the achievements made by teaching material of Modern Chinese edited by Huang Borong and Liao Xudong, the author has found some more questions in succession in the course of teaching on the following aspects, that is, the parts of speech of the Chinese word ＂fei chang＂, the classification of the Chinese word ＂gong tong＂, query of examples of appositive phrases and examples of object preposition, query of ＂suo＂ phrases and inversion sentences, frame-pattern or ladder-pattern sentence structure, the confirmation of the inner relationship of multiple compound sentences. So in this article, the author puts forward some different opinions on the above aspects to discuss with professionals in this field.