刑法基本原则拷问——试论“法律面前人人平等”不适为刑法的基本原则

Questioning the Basic Criminal Law Principle——On "All People Are Equal before the Law" Is not Appropriate to the Basic Principle of Criminal Law

本文从法理学角度入手,分析阐释了关涉法律原则问题的基本概念源流,从法律原则的功能价值切入,从宪法原则与部门法原则的区割展开,界定了部门法基本原则得以确立的基本要求,并以此为依据,在又讨论“刑法基本原则是一功能与价值体序”是一命题的同时,置疑和拷问了作为刑法法定基本原则之一的“法律面前人人平等”原则的合理性。

This paper, from the perspective of jurisprudence, analyzes and interprets basic concepts and originals with which the Law Principle is concerned. It also defines basic demands on which sector law principles are established from the perspective of functions and values of the Law Principle and from distinguishing the Constitution Principle and sector law principles. It, thereupon, discusses that ＂the Criminal Law Principle is a system of functions and values＂, and meanwhile queries and questions that ＂All people are equal before the law＂ as one of the legal basic principles of the Criminal Law is rational.