在积极与消极之间:司法的权利保护——首起“编曲权”纠纷案的法理思考刘练军,周述荣

Between Judicial Activism and Judicial Restraint: Judicial Protection of Right —— Exploring the Right of Melody-composition in Jurisprudence

该文以2003年判决的一个案例为切入口,提出了“编曲”是一种独创行为的观点。认为司法应该积极地保护权利,在特定境况下采取积极主义、进行权利推定,以实现司法公平、正义之价值目标。

After analyzing the related instances and judicial process of a case in 2003, the authors comment vnth the jurisprudential method, and suggest that melody-composition is an original creation. It should be protected positively by judicature and in some special situation activism should be adopted in judicial process in order to realize impartiality and justice of judicature.