关于罗斯福时代新政“宪法革命”的几点浅见被引量：4

Some Thoughts on “the Constitutional Revolution” of the New Deal

导出

摘要美国宪法的若干重要法理原则及其运用在富兰克林·罗斯福总统任内发生了巨大变化,史称新政“宪法革命”。不过,这种变化并不是在所谓1937年最高法院的“及时转向”中一锤定音的。最高法院在正当程序、商业权、公众福利条款上的态度及其变化充分说明,新政宪法革命无论是从当时还是其后的发展来看都有它的连续性、局限性和复杂性。只有认识到了这一点,我们对新政宪法革命乃至于整个新政的历史评价才会比较准确。 During the administration of President Franklin Roosevelt, both jurisprudential understanding and judicial application of several major clauses of the U.S. Constitution underwent a significant change, which has been called by historians as “the Constitutional Revolution” of the New Deal. However, such change was not done at one stroke in the Supreme Court’s “switch in time” in 1937. The Court’s changing view of due process, commerce power, and general welfare clearly demonstrated the continuity, limitation, and complexity of “the Constitutional Revolution” both at that time and in its later development. Only from this perspective can we have an appraisal of “the Constitutional Revolution” of the New Deal and the New Deal itself as a whole that might be more accurate in historical terms.

作者韩铁

机构地区南开大学世界近现代史研究中心

出处《世界历史》 CSSCI 北大核心 2006年第4期29-40,共12页 World History

基金教育部人文社会科学重点研究基地重大项目"世界近现代史上的政治民主化问题"[项目批准号:04JJD770001]的阶段性成果

关键词宪法革命正当程序商业权公众福利司法审查双重标准

分类号 K712.53 [历史地理—世界史]

引文网络
相关文献

参考文献54

1玛丽安·C.麦克钠.《富兰克林·罗斯福和宪法大战:1937年改组法院危机》(Marian C.McKenna,Franklin Roosevelt and the Great Constitutional War:The Court-Packing Crisis of 1937),纽约2002年版,第96页.
2塞缪尔·罗斯曼编.《富兰克林·D.罗斯福公共文件和演说集》(Samuel I.Rosenman,ed.,The Public Papers and Addresses of Franklin D.Roosevelt)第4卷,纽约1950年版,第200-222页.
3威廉·E.洛克滕堡.《富兰克林·D.罗斯福的改组法院计划:再生、再死》(William E.Leuchtenburg,"FDR's Court-Packing Plan:A Second Life,A Second Death"),《杜克法律评论》(Duke Law Journal)第35卷,1985年,第673页.
4G.爱德华·怀特.《宪法与新政》(G.Edward White,The Constitution and the New Deal),马萨诸塞州剑桥2000年版,第16-17页,第13-32页,第198页.
5劳拉·卡尔曼 LauraKalman.《法律、政治和新政》（ "Law,Politics,and the New Deal（s）"）[J].耶鲁法律杂志,1999,108:2167-2167,2188.
6布鲁斯·阿克曼.《我们人民:转变》(Bruce Ackerman,We the People:Transformations),马萨诸塞州剑桥1998年版,第343,291页.
7威廉·E.洛克滕堡.《最高法院的再生:罗斯福时代的宪法革命》(William E.Leuchtenburg,The Supreme Court Reborn:The Constitutional Revolution in the Age of Roosevelt),纽约1995年版,第213-236页.
8理查德·D.弗里德曼 Richard D.Friedman.《转向之时和其他的思想试验：休斯法院和宪法改变》（ "Switching Time and Other Thought Experiments：The Hughes Court and Constitutional Transformation"）[J].宾夕法尼亚大学法律评论,1994,142:1891-1984.
9莫尔黑德诉纽约州案(Morehead v.New York ex rel.Tipaldo),《美国判决书汇编》第298卷,1936年,第587,618-631页[298U.S.587,618-31(1936)].
10西岸旅馆诉帕里什案[West Coast Hotel Co.v.Parrish,300 U.S.379,391(1937)].

二级参考文献71

1Bernard H. Siegan, Property and Freedom : The Constitution, the Courts, and Land-Use Reulation (New Brunswick, N. J. : Transaction Publishers, 1997), pp. 5-9.
2James W. Ely, Jr. , The Guardian of Every Other Rights : A Constitutional History of Property Rights (New York: Oxford University Press, 1998), p. 134.
3Bernard H. Siegan, Property Rights : From Magna Carta to the Fourteenth Amendment (New Brunswick, N. J. : Transaction Publishers, 2001), pp. 123-126, 286-287.
4A. W. B. Simpson, "Land Ownership and Economic Freedom," in Harry N. Scheiber, ed. ,The State and Freedom of Contract (Stanford, California: Stanford University Press, 1998),p. 17.
5J. Pepter Byrne, "What We Talk about When We Talk about Property Rights : A Response to Carol Rose's Property as the Keystone Right.?"Notre Dame Law Review, Vol. 71, 1996,p. 1049.
6Edward S. Corwin, "The Basic Doctrine of American Constitutional Law," Michigan Law Review, Vol. 12 , 1914, pp. 247-276.
7Edward J. Erler, "The Great Fence to Liberty: The Right to Property in the American Founding," in Ellen Frankel Paul & Howard Dickman, eds. , Liberty, Property, &. the Foundation of the American Constitution (Albany: State University of New York Press, 1989), pp. 43-63.
8Gregory S. Alexander, Commodity and Propriety : Competing Visions of Property in American Legal Thought, 1776-1970 (Chicago: University of Chicago Press, 1997), pp. 60-71.
9Charles Francis Adams, ed. , The Works of John Adams (Boston.. Little, Brown and Company, 1851), Vol. 6, p. 280.
10Max Farrand, ed. , The Records of the Federal Convention of 1787 (New Haven.. Yale University Press, 1966), p. 147.