浅谈《人体器官移植技术临床应用管理暂行规定》的九点不足

ON the Oversight of “Temporary provisions Of Human Organ transplanting Technology Clinical practice”

就新施行的《人体器官移植技术临床应用管理暂行规定》,提出其立法目的表述不妥;缺乏与其他法律法规之间的平衡和协调;未能明确提出按照公平效率原则分配器官;缺乏对未成年人的特殊保护;过分强调捐赠者对器官捐赠协议的任意撤消权;书面同意形式的局限性;未就禁止买卖原则的情形具体化;未能就建立具有中立性特点的器官调控中心作出规定;未能就脑死亡留下一个开放性的口子等九点不足,并提出了建议。

＂Temporary provisions Of Human Organ transplanting Technology Clinical practice＂has some oversight, such as, the unexpressly stated legislative goal, the inconsistency wih other statutes, the inefficiecy and unfairness in the distribution of human organs,no special protection of minors, too much protection of the donor＇s right of rescission , restriction to written agreement, too general prohition on the sale of human organs and no neutral agencies to manage the distribution of human organs etc. This article put forward some solutions to these problems.