背反还是必然——兼评谢维营教授对“人民内部矛盾”提法的反思

Counter-productiveness or Certainty:On Professor Xie Wei-ying's Reflection to the Wording of "the Contradictions among the People"

谢维营教授将毛泽东政治实践中“人民内部矛盾”的提法“越是重视越得不到正确处理”等背反现象的原因归结为理论上存在缺陷、逻辑上也不完善。然而,“人民内部矛盾”提法不仅具有自在的逻辑背景,也是毛泽东式的话语体系在特定历史场景下的逻辑表述,其政治实践中为达成个人神圣的具有绝对权威的意志,具有自延安时期以来历史的、逻辑的、一以贯之的联系。

Professor Xie Wei - ying owes to the defectiveness of the theory and imperfectness of its logic those counterpro- ductive phenomena： the higher one sets a value on something, the harder it will be right treated, as in the wording of ＂Contradictions among the People＂ put forth by Mao Ze -dong in his political practice. However, the wording of ＂Contradictions among the People＂ not only possesses its logic background but also is the logical expressions of Mao＇ s typical wording system in the particular historic occasions, whose immanent thoughts to realize his holy goal of absolute authority in his political practice has persisted in its historical and logistic consistency since the Yan＇an period.