从学术层面看阎崇年、易中天史学演讲的微瑕

Flaws in History Lectures by Yan Chongnian and Yi Zhongtian

在中央电视台“百家讲坛”十分走红的阎崇年、易中天的史学演讲中,都出现了不该出现的学术错误:前者认为中国古代凡是统一王朝后代利用前代皇宫概无一例,这显然不符合史实;后者描绘的秦亡之后刘邦进出汉中的路线,也一错再错,与史实大相径庭。

There existed certain flaws that should not have occurred in history lectures made by Yan Chongnian and Yi Zhongtian in CCTV Forum of miscellaneous schools：the former believes that there is no such case that in ancient China, the unified dynasty made use of the palace of the preceding dynasty,which obviously goes against historical facts;the latter presented the route along which Li Bang went of Hanzhong after the collapse of Qing Dynasty,which also goes far away from historical facts.