94例精神疾病司法复核鉴定案例回顾性分析

Retrospective Analysis of 94 cases of Mental illness for Judicatory Re-authentication

目的分析近三年安徽省精神疾病司法复核鉴定案例。方法选取2003年以来在我中心进行精神疾病司法复核鉴定的大部分病例,共94例。采用一般描述性统计分析,检验方法主要采用配对设计下多组资料频数分布的λ2检验。结果在复核鉴定案例中,以男性、青壮年、初中以下文化程度者和无业者为多,涉及案件类型以杀人、伤害、强奸和民事纠纷等社会危害较大的案件为主,公安机关提交的复核鉴定案例较多;在鉴定结论中,精神分裂症占绝大多数,与首次鉴定结论比较,表现为首次鉴定以人格障碍、情感性精神障碍较多,在责任能力评定时,限定责任能力评判较少。结论对精神疾病的司法鉴定,各级鉴定机构应当特别慎重,如果存在疑异,提请复核鉴定是有必要的。

Objective To describe and analyze mental illness judicatory re - authenticated cases from Hefei Psychiatry Hospital in past three years. Method 94 mental illness cases for judicatory re - authentication since 2003 were selected. Description statistics analysis and ehi - square test were used. Result Among the re - authenticated cases, most were male, young, low education background and unemployment persons. The types of crimes mainly included homicide, hurt, rape etc. In re -authenticated conclusion, the schizophrenia disease was majority. In the first authenticated conclusion, personality obstacle and the emotion spirit obstacle were majority. In the responsibility ability assessment, the limit responsibility ability was less. Conclusion In judicatory authentication of mental illness cases, authenticating organizations at various levels should be careful and apply for to re - authentication if some people had different opinion.