司法审查的普通法之维——评《普通法与自由主义理论》

The Common Law Dimension of Judicial Review——Review on Common Law and Liberal Theory

在《普通法与自由主义理论》一书中,尽管斯托纳追溯了美国司法审查的普通法渊源,但是他并未能揭示出普通法与美国司法审查之间的内在理论联系;根据哈耶克的理论,认为两者间的理论关系在于它们对正当行为规则的遵循,进而对司法审查的普通法分析所可能面临的批评进行了申辩。

This article thinks that Stoner can not disclose the theoretical relation between oommon law and American judicial review though he examines the origin of American judicial review in the tradition of oommon law. Acoording to Hayek＇s theory 1 argue that the theoretical relation lies in their abiding by rules of just conduct. Then 1 analyze criticism for the argument.