残本《曲谱大成》与《九宫大成》的比较研究——《九宫大成》曲文、曲乐材料来源考之二

Comparative Study of Incomplete a Collection of Lyrics and a Collection of Nine Gongs

本文结合《九宫大成》的相关材料,对中国国家图书馆、首都图书馆藏《曲谱大成》进行了较全面的考证,补充论证了一些时贤尚未讨论或有失妥当的问题。本文认为“郑捐本”系《曲谱大成》南曲部分的残谱,除残缺8种宫调的曲牌外,还缺少南曲的犯调部分;“总论本”与《曲谱大成》同属一个系统,但亦残缺不全;“北曲本”4种宫调曲牌基本上可以确定为《曲谱大成》的北曲部分;而“零抄本”与《曲谱大成》不属于一个系统。《九宫大成》对于《曲谱大成》的继承主要体现在集曲、具体曲牌、曲牌谱式、曲论等方面。

Combining with relative materials of A Collection of Nine Gongs , the paper makes comprehensive textual research on A Collection of Lyrics collected by National Library of China and the Capital Library. It expounds in addition some problems that are not discussed or inappropriately concluded so far. A Collection of Nine Gongs carries onA Collection of Lyrics in aspects of collected lyrics, concrete name of the tunes, tunes name and music score forms and music theory.