再论图书馆学理论研究与建构的方法论问题——对我国“图书馆精神”研究与争鸣的反思

More Thoughts on the Methodology for Research and Construction of the Theory of Library Science——Reflection on the Research and Contention on "Library Spirit" in China

本文从哲学方法论角度对业界图书馆精神的研究与争鸣现象进行了反思,认为学术研究与争鸣应首先明确论题中的主要概念,遵循逻辑学基本原理;要应用联系与发展的历史观与唯物辩证法去思考图书馆精神研究现象,从现象中把握本质。文章在明确了"图书馆精神"诸概念与揭示了业界图书馆精神研究的本质的基础上,对程焕文、于良芝的图书馆精神理论进行了评析,并对黄俊贵与程焕文的图书馆精神争鸣发表了自己的见解,对黄俊贵的论点做了简要批驳。

This paper reflects the phenomenon of research and discussion in library spirit in our circles from philosophic methodology point. It deems that we should first make the primary concept clearly and obey the basic logical principle while doing academic research and discussion. We should ponder the phenomenon of research in library spirit by means of historical conception of connection and development and materialistic dialectics, so as to grasp the essence from phenomenon.It evaluates and analyses Cheng Huanwen and Yu Liangzhi＇s theory on library spirit after clarifying the conception of library spirit and revealing the essence of research in library spirit in this circles. The author announces his own view on the contention about the library spirit between Cheng Huanwen and Huang Jungui, and does some brief criticism on HuangJungui＇s point of view as well.