核心期刊评价功能之检讨

On the Review of Core Journal Evaluation Function

核心期刊已经越来越引起人们的关注,在有些高校和科研单位把论文能否发表在核心期刊作为奖励和职称晋级的依据,核心期刊的作用日益凸显,已全然演变成了一种评价尺度,已逐渐成为学术理论期刊的一种身份、地位的标志,对职称评定愈来愈发挥着"重要的作用"。核心期刊评价功能所产生的歧异和误导作用,是连核心期刊的研制者都始料不及的。应当针对目前"核心期刊"现象对核心期刊的由来和初始目的以及泛化、异化、评价功能等进行剖析和理论阐述,以正本清源,还核心期刊的科学定位。

Core periodical has absorbed much concern from people and now in some institutions of higher education and research units it has become one important factor in awarding and promotion in one＇ s professional title. Since the important role core periodical is playing it has turned to be an evaluation standard, a sign of academic periodical＇s dignity and functions more and more in the assess of professional titles. Core periodical ＇ s misleading and discrimination in the assessing system is unpredictable even by core periodical itself. This essay discusses and describes the core periodical phenomenon from its origin, initial purpose, flooding, dissimilation and its assessing function in order to effect radical reform and thus give the scientific definition of core periodical.