李壁《王荆文公诗笺注》误收五首考述

LI Bi Wang Jing Wen Gong Poetry Paper Note Receives by Mistake Five to Test States

李壁《王荆文公诗笺注》所收集的王诗,虽比《临川先生文集》多出72首,但其中明显有误收。对其中一些误收的作品进行探讨,是必要的。不过综观学界已有的讨论,大都均以直接判定为多,而以分析说理为少。这样的讨论往往显得猜测有余而研究不足,令人觉得说服力不强。一般而言,判断一篇作品是否属于误收,应当要展示出令人信服的依据来。故本文试图重在突出事实根据,对一些误收之作力求搜寻出相关的人物事迹和版本年代来,然后再以这些史实为依据,用来证明其确系误收。

LI Bi Wang Jing Wen Gong Poetry Paper Note（《王荆文公诗笺注》） collects Wang poems, although are more than 72 Linchuan Gentleman Anthology （《临川先生文集》）, but obvious errors receives.The work received by mistake which to some carries on the discussion, is necessary.But the comprehensive survey educational world had the discussion, taking directly determines most as much, but taking analysis and reasons as few.Such discussion often appears with the guess to have Yu Er to study the insufficiency, making one think the persuasive power is not strong.Generally speaking, judging a work of whether receive by mistake, must have to demonstrate the persuasive basis.Therefore this article attempts again on the prominent fact basis, receives the work endeavour to some to search for the correlation by mistake of the character fact and the edition age.Then again take these historical evidence as the basis, to prove its mistake.