文字、词汇和涵义——商代甲骨研究的三部参考著作

Graphs,Words,and Meanings:Three Reference Works for Shang Oracle-Bone Studies

本文对《殷墟甲骨刻辞摹释总集》、《殷墟甲骨刻辞类纂》和《甲骨文字字释综览》三部著作进行学术评论,指出了其得失。

This paper gives academic comments on the following three works： General Collection of Compiled Comments on Oracle Bone Inscription in Yin Ruin, Classification of Oracle Bone Inscription in Yin Ruin and Overview of Explanatinn of Oracle Bone Inscription in Yin Ruin, The above mentioned three works are helpful for scholars who study special Graphs, Words, and Meanings in collections of oracle bone inscriptions. The first one is a necessary updating of the index by Shima Kunio. The second one represents modernization and development of the first one. All of them are very important academic resources. Two of them are published in Beijing. We are supposed to be cautious when applying, especially the second one.