王维生卒年陈说质疑——以陈铁民《王维生年新探》为商评的重点

Wang Wei's Years of Birth and Death Issue Challenged——With Chen Ticmin's New Explorations of Wang Wei's Year of Birth as the key to the discussion

中华书局版陈铁民《王维集校注》附录五之《王维年谱》,据《王维生年新探》一文所系订的王维生卒年,均无以接受材料的检验,而使之成为了与史实不相符合的错误。本文对其所依据的材料及其这些错误的因由,进行了逐一考辨与检验,同时对流行于王维研究界的"兄生弟后"之现象进行了简要剖析。

According to Wang Wei＇s years of birth and death published in Chen Tiemin＇s New Explorations of Wang Wei＇ s Year of Birth, Chronicle of Wang Wei of Appendix V ofChen Tiemin＇s Wang Wei＇ s Collection of Annotation to Wang Wei is checked unacceptable and becomes an error incompatible to historical facts. This paper makes a close examination and inspection of the supportive materials and the reasons why these errors appear. Meanwhile, a brief analysis is made of the phenomenon of ＂elder brother＇s birth date later than younger brother＂ prevalent in the research circle of Wang Wei.