战国简卦画问题再探讨

Re-probing into Painting of Divinatory Symbols of Slips of the Warring States

包山简、天星观简、新蔡简等战国楚简中有成对出现的易卦,学术界一般都把这些成对的易卦看做是楚占中变卦的本卦和之卦,把这些易卦看做是卦。但是,这样的结论也存在疑点,仍是一个需要探讨的问题。这些易卦可能并不是卦,而是真正的卦画,基中的符号可能并不是数字,而是几种不同的记爻符;成对的易卦,也许并不是变卦的本卦和之卦,很可能是两次筮占的结果。

There was the pair Yi divinatory symbols in the slips of the Warring States. Academics generally regard this pair Yi divinatory symbols as Ben divinatory symbols and Zhi divinatory symbols in Bian divinatory symbols, and regard these Yi divinatory symbols as divinatory symbols. But there are some doubts to this conclusion; this is still a problem that need explore. These Yi divinatory symbols probably are not divinatory symbols, but are the real paintings of divinatory symbols. The symbols probably are not digits, only are a few different Fu. The pair Yi divinatory symbols maybe are not Ben divinatory symbols and Zhi divinatory symbols in Bian divinatory symbols, probably are two resuits of Sift Zhan.