“唯京房为异党”说考辨

Research and discrimination on the theory of "JING Fang's Yi-ology is nothing but a heterodox"

京房《易》学是西汉《易》学之重要一家。由于后世对《汉纪》、《汉书》中记述其材料认识和理解的偏差,以致造成了"唯京房为异党"之说。本文从材料来源、语句意义及京房《易》在汉代的地位等三方面对此说法进行了考辨,指出了此说不当之所在。

JING Fang＇s Yi-ology is one of the most important in the Western Han Dynasty. Later-generation scholars＇ understanding deviated from the records in the Hart ji （The Annals of the Han Dynasty） by XUN Yue and Hart shu （The History of the Han Dynasty） mainly complied by BAN Gu, consequently, they made a theory of ＂JING Fang＇s Yi-ology is nothing but a heterodox＂. This paper discusses the theory and mainly points out its incorrectness in three aspects： the source of the materials, the meaning of the sentences and the academic standing of the JING＇s Yi-ology in the Han Dynasty.