拆迁案件评说——实务与理论的二维探讨

Discussion on the dismantlement case——on both practical and theoretical perspectives

本文关注的是日益增多的拆迁纠纷。通过对亲历及收集的实际案例加以总结。笔者大致描绘出拆迁案件主要的法律关系,并提出主要法律争议焦点在于颁发拆迁许可证的合法性、拆迁人资格的认定、征地与拆迁的关系及安置补偿问题。其次从理论探讨的角度出发,以实现社会正义为价值目标,笔者对现有的制度框架中的立法位阶、公益界定、强拆的合法性提出疑问,并在一定程度上寻求更加正当化的制度建构。

This paper focuses on the increasing disputes related to the dismantlement, summarizes assembled cases showing up lately, and depicts the legal relationship and issues in the dismantlement case. On a theoretical term, this paper aims at realize the social justice and questions the present systems, based on which seeks a more justified construction of systems.