综合行政执法的理论困惑与反思

Confusion and Reflection on Comprehensive Administrative Law Enforcement

综合行政执法从实践中产生,进入制度实施以来,综合行政执法已经取得了很大实效,其价值和意义不断被发现。与此同时,相关的理论争议也一直不断,甚至有人质问综合行政执法是否有存在的价值和意义,提出停止试点的观点。对这些问题不加以澄清,势必影响综合行政执法的进一步发展。为此,文章对综合行政执法的合法性、实效性以及路径选择等质疑加以归纳与反思,对综合行政执法的性质和价值加以进一步思考。

Since arising from the practice,especially in the period of system implementation,comprehensive administrative law enforcement has made great substantial results,and its value and significance have been constantly discovered.At the same time,the disputes on theory have existed for a long time,and some people even questioned whether it is valuable and significant for comprehensive administrative law enforcement to exist,and they put forward establishing the experimental unit stopping its enforcement.If these issues are not clarified,it is bound to affect consolidation of further development.Therefore,we should induce and rethink on the legality,effectiveness and path selection of comprehensive administrative law enforcement,and on its nature and value as well.