刑事法治视野下热点案件的困境与出路——以许霆案为样本

The corner and outlet of hot cases under the view of criminal law——Take XuTing case by example

广州中院一审对许霆案的定罪和量刑有着充分的刑法依据。二审判决很大程度上是司法对民意的屈从。民众意见与司法认定的激烈冲突是当前我国类似热点案件面临的主要困境。公众诉求与法治样态的错位,司法与民众沟通的长期阻隔,以及过分依赖修改法律而不重视解释法律,是造成此种困境的深层原因。回到规范判断,立足法律挖掘案件背后的问题,才是法治视野下应当坚持的理性立场和对热点案件关注的真实回归。

The sentence on XuTing case Guangzhou made is strictly under the criminal law. There is a conflict between people desire and the justice, which come into being the main comer of hot cases. The lack of communication of justice and the people and the frequently depending on modifying laws but ignore explaining them are the deep reasons of this comer. We should back to the criterion,make judgement according to the law and find out the issue behind the cases.